Student News Action Network

It was a common occurrence while living in India that my family and I would cringe whenever we were asked where we were from. We would gulp after replying with, “we’re from the USA,” as predictable facial expressions dawned on the questioner’s faces. From their smile you could tell that words like obesity, ignorance, prosperity, power, and arrogance crossed their minds. So what? Every country has its faults. However, it was obvious that they were thinking of the most embarrassing representation of our country, aka President Bush. Some inquirers even followed up their question with, “so, did you vote for Bush?” We were then relieved to react, appalled, at the sound of his name.

Although it had been bad enough living in Bethesda and watching him continuously make it more and more embarrassing to be a part of this nation, it got worse when we left for India and then became representatives of the Bush nation. At both of the international schools I attended overseas, Canadian International School (Bangalore) and the American Embassy School (New Delhi), the lack of intelligence and actions of President Bush were used against me in judgment. I was constantly rebutting negative comments made about the US, but eventually I just gave up. By the end of my three years in India, I was anti-American. I would defend America when necessary, but when people went off on tangents about the so-called common oblivion among Americans and jokes about recent Bushisms, I’d either leave it alone or join in.

It took me a while to feel like it was all wrong. There’s a lot of nationalism in India, a progressive country with so much potential, and here I was insulting my own country. Watching the effect of power America has while you’re living abroad, especially in a place like India where they need all the help they can get, like providing education and proper living conditions for all their people, really changes a person’s perspective. Most people like to say that you shouldn’t care about what everyone thinks of you, but when it comes to being the most powerful nation in the world, you realize how important it is for your leader to represent you well.

In America, we live in utter comfort. We don’t watch bombs explode outside our houses or watch them carry away the dead bodies, as most do in Baghdad. Even rapidly developing countries such as India have so much to take care of. Their poverty is still out of control, they need to work on education, and the tax system and the law enforcement can be very corrupt. Americans don’t deal with this on a daily basis and if they did, they might rethink before doing a few common things in their lives. They might change their mind before saying they believe the war in Iraq is what’s best for everyone. I walked past a “jhuggi” or a slum on my way to school in Delhi every morning. It was filled with over 2,000 people in an area smaller than our own school campus. That alone taught me so much about not wasting the things I’m privileged to have, and to also appreciate what I have.

Things are constantly changing in India and how people felt about President Bush changed dramatically around springtime in 2006. He came to Delhi to meet with Prime Minister Manmohan Singh about the ongoing nuclear deal that was to be settled. There were several protests, dominantly Muslim protesters, against President Bush’s visit as they believed him to be a war criminal and an enemy of Islam. They condemned the invasion in Iraq, did not wish to welcome him to their country, and considered the nuclear deal to be another way of making India a “US lackey,” an insult to India. After how President Bush showed his reasoning behind the Iraq war, I couldn’t blame the protestors, because I could see the connection they were making between their religion and the many deaths in other Muslim nations as a result of a US army invasion. President Bush stayed at the Marayah Sheraton, not too far from my house. He wasn’t the only guest. He maxed out the entire hotel with his security and even bomb sniffing dogs. It was insulting to many that the President of the United States was spending government money to house his security dogs at one of the nicest hotels in Delhi. I was also appalled when I saw many of the street roundabouts aligned with India flags and USA flags, one after the other. It felt like a symbol of arrogance. “He is here.” Things proceeded and he returned to Washington. Thank goodness. I spent my last two years in India with the same feelings towards Bush and the US.

I returned home in June, with hope that our new leader to be elected that fall, wouldn’t fill people like me such shame. Right before the election, the nuclear deal with India was finalized. This “deal” was to remove international sanctions against India and allow it to buy fuel for its civilian nuclear reactors, and to gain access to nuclear technology, investment, and expertise. It overturned a 34-year-old regime of nuclear isolation from India, imposed after it shocked the world with the 1974 atomic explosion which indicated that it had produced nuclear weapons. The sanctions continued because India had refused to sign the Nuclear Proliferation Treaty (NPT) or the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty. Suddenly all the pieces came together. The US and India are two of the world’s largest democracies, both engaged in conflicts with militant Islamists, India is in dire need of more and better power sources, and the US was now in an economic recession and could definitely use the profits from exchanging with India. India was now much more pro-Bush, because they now have access to the power sources they need to move forward with their continuously booming economy. With my love for India, I was actually very proud that the government was successful with providing this deal with India. It was the first time I was happy to say President Bush did something right. I took close note of how Bush spent his last few weeks or so in office.

As January 20, 2009 came and left, it was no surprise that the media and the American people have definitely shown their mixed feelings towards former President Bush’s departure from the White House. Tabloids lined the shelves with headings talking about Bush in a depressed, drinking state and even announcing that the Bushes were supposedly getting a divorce after his term ended. Although it has been accurately noted by reputable sources that Bush did have a problem with excessive drinking in the past, it’s not quite as serious as these tabloids are displaying it. Believe it or not. According to an interview with Diane Sawyer and former First Lady Laura Bush, he stopped drinking. “"I doubt I would be standing here if I hadn't quit drinking whiskey and beer and wine and all that," President Bush told ABC's Martha Raddatz in an interview at an earlier time in 2008. Living in a “Land of Bush” and attending an international school certainly provides contrasts of the perceptions of Bush’s presidency as many students carry their feelings from their original nations.

Aside from what has been done in the past, everyone is skeptical about what will happen now and in the next four years. It is quite evident that the American Democrats are more than ecstatic to see Bush’s departure. Just Google “Bush’s last day” and you’ll find pages dedicated to celebrating his last day in office. The most famous is, unsurprisingly, www.bushslastday.com, the host of the trademark, 01.20.09. On the website, they state: “A day that will live in history...01.20.09® celebrates the end of the Bush years, and the historic inauguration of Barack Obama. This simple iconic date has become a symbol for change and is the only registered trademark celebrating this historic date. Join us in celebrating Bush's Last Day!”

You can buy pins, t-shirts, balloons, coffee mugs, you name it. As strange as it may seem though, there’s not much left to criticize as we’re waiting upon our new President Obama to take up the issues Bush has left behind. Democratic America hasn’t really given Bush “the finger” as he leaves us, however it would be unnecessary since the Iraqi journalist, Muntadar al-Zaidi, basically fulfilled that task when he threw his shoes at Bush during a press conference in Iraq in December 2008. I wasn’t too sure how I felt about this. In some ways, I wished that I could have done the same. I’m sure many people would have liked to have thrown something at Bush. All joking aside, he was the president of the United States and I grudgingly feel he deserved more respect than having shoes thrown at him during his last visit to Iraq.

In terms of presentation, the Bushes did well at the inauguration. The ceremony in which the new first family, along with the Bidens, bid farewell to the Bushes was almost humorous; watching the new president and first lady say goodbye to the Bushes as if they had just come for dinner. It was quite a sight to watch the legendary former President Bush get on the helicopter and fly out of Washington. Symbolic, in some way. Although the former president did well in leaving his reputation in India on a high note, I felt relief as I saw him disappear. I knew that my fellow American friends back in Delhi would have to face the shame of him no longer. As for our new President Barack Obama, we can only hope for the best. Around the world people see him as a symbol of hope, world peace, and it’s evident that good will come with this new presidency. I know that Americans outside their home country will now show pride for their country without the shadow of Bush behind them.

Tags: north_america, south_asia

Reply to This

Replies to This Article

Nice article! It is really true. Even though I am not American (I'm Canadian), I always think to myself, 'wow, I would have felt pretty bad to answer that question if I were American'. But I think it's interesting, and really good-- that now with the election of Obama-- even people who are not American do kind of wish they were American. At first I was so excited to get out of the country to go to university in Canada, but now I'm kind of sad I wont be able to keep up as well with American politics and be part of its new spirit.

Reply to This

Very interesting article, highlights the difficulties of being a Third Culture Kid

Reply to This

Good Job! You have an amazing writing style, and I truly agree with you. As an American overseas myself I know what you have experienced, I am a big Obama supporter, and hope that someday I may be proud of my nation.
Katie Eliot

Reply to This

I like this article, it addresses what a lot of people feel towards the United States and towards Bush. The last paragraph though is putting Obama on a high pedestal. But needless to say, everyone is happy to see Bush go.

Amelia Chacon

Reply to This

I can understand the negative stereotypes people have of Americans, and its effects on Americans (especially those living overseas). Being half American and half Thai (and having never lived in the USA) , I always announce I am Thai first. I never really noticed that I felt no pride as an American until I heard about the journalist throwing his shoe at Bush; I actually laughed.

Lily

Reply to This

I have to admit that I do sometimes generalize Americans and even joke about them, but their mocking always leave a bad aftertaste. There is a sense that picking on America is justified because of all the damage that it had done to other countries in the world and its people.

-Yenning

Reply to This

Great article! :) Having lived in Doha, Qatar for the past 12 years, I completely understand what you’re getting at. Not only was Bush the topic of much political and humorous banter, but so was the supposed ignorance of all Americans. People from the USA, including myself, always came back from the summer with ridiculous stories about how people would ask if we rode camels to school or lived in tents, stories that only hurt our situation. At times, it can seem rather exhausting to dispute those who claim stereotypical or generalized notions when I myself have seen some examples of the things people are making fun of Americans for. However, I always wish people could, especially in an international environment, realize how hypocritical it is to claim that Americans view people a certain way when they are stereotyping Americans in much the same manner. All in all, though, I think most people can agree that the “reign of Bush” had a fair amount of problems, whether you’re a Democrat or Republican, American or other nationality. Let’s hope that the optimism you carried through the last paragraph (in regards in Obama) holds true!

-Ashlee Goedken

Reply to This

Well, first of all, great article!!! Really well written and I like the way you sound so personal when talking about this issue, which is good because when it comes to you own country, it is right to talk this way. Let me tell you, I have sort of the same problem when it comes to other nations talking about my country Venezuela and its government. President Hugo Chavez, who is responsible for Venezuela's worst social-political and economical situation, is basically a God internationally, except for those who actually know what goes on in Venezuela, which frankly are quite a few. Every time I introduced myself to anyone the conversation is always something similar to this: " Hi, I'm John/Mohammad/Jose/Nianzu (anyone from anywhere) what's your name?" "Oh, Hi I'm Ali Rodriguez I'm from Venezuela" "Oh CHAVEZ we love that guy over here man he's awesome isn't he?" " Ehmm not really let me tell you about my country. . ." and we would begin a unnecessary political conversation just because most of the people in the world are misinformed about Hugo Chavez. Chavez is not dumb though, I give him that.He knows that as long as Venezuela he has oil to give away every time he wants and by opposing the convenient people in a fight ( like for example opposing Israel in the Israeli/Palestinian conflict just to get the affection of the Arab World) no one will ever know, well, no one will ever WANT to know to the truth about who he really is and what he really does.

- Ali Rodriguez

Reply to This

Great article, the subject is very interesting. I really liked your point of view, as an American filled with such an international background. I am not American myself, but living in this country gives me the same thoughts of embarrassment to the nation's representative (well at that time of course). You made it very clear how usually you shouldn't care about what people think but when it comes to such a powerful country like the US, it is important to be represented well, and avoid such a bad reputation.

Reply to This

Good job! This article addresses many of the issues people felt towards America during the Bush years. Its a shame that an entire nation must be judged due to its leader. I hope your optimism about Obama holds true though!

Ben

Reply to This

RSS

Navigation

© 2010   Created by Mark Schulte.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service